“You shall dwell in sukkos for seven days.” (Vayikra 23:42)
For most people in Eretz Yisroel, Sukkos is a very enjoyable yom tov, as the weather is quite pleasant. But outside of the holy land, many Jews live in climates where rain, or at times even snow, makes it difficult to remain in the sukkah. The Mishnah and the Gemora discuss how one is meant to internalize the message that Hashem is sending when rain (or worse) prevents us from fulfilling the mitzvah of Sukkah.
There is, however, a puzzling halacha that deserves attention. Even if it is raining on the first night of Sukkos, one is still obligated to eat in the sukkah. This gemora derives this from a gezera shava comparing the 15th of Nissan to the 15th of Tishrei: just as one must eat matzah on the first night of Pesach, so too one must eat in the sukkah on the first night of Sukkos. This halacha applies even in inclement weather, despite the usual exemption of mitzta’er (a person who is exempt from sukkah when the conditions cause undue suffering).
The Teshuvos Oneg Yom Tov (Rabbi Yom Tov Lipman Heilpern 1816-1879) raises a fascinating difficulty. A sukkah is consecrated for the mitzvah, and therefore one who sits in the sukkah at a time when he is not obligated – such as during a downpour – is considered to be benefiting from something that is muktzah l’mitzvasah, set aside exclusively for the mitzvah. Doing so is forbidden. If so, how can one eat in the sukkah on the first night during a downpour? Wouldn’t he be violating the prohibition of benefiting from muktzah?
Rav Shach (Rabbi Elazar Menachem Man Shach 1899-2001) offers a fascinating answer. The exemption from sitting in the sukkah when the weather is inclement is based on teishvu k’ein taduru – one must sit in the sukkah just as he sits in his home. If one would not remain in his own home under certain conditions, he is exempt from remaining in the sukkah under those same conditions. But, Rav Shach explains, there are situations in which a person would remain in his home despite discomfort – because something very important happening is happening there. If a person’s home were experiencing leaks, cold, or other unpleasant conditions, yet something significant were taking place inside, he would stay. The first night of Sukkos is such a moment; therefore, even in the rain the sukkah is a place one must be.
*(I have a question on this approach. If this logic is correct, then on the first night one should actually fulfill the mitzvah of teishvo even in the rain. Yet the normative psak is that although one must eat in the sukkah, he does not fulfill the mitzvah and therefore does not make a brocho of “leishev basukkah”. According to Rav Shach, shouldn’t he be fulfilling the mitzvah and therefore making a brocho?)
Regardless, whether due to rain, cold, or heat, people sometimes find it difficult to sit in the sukkah. Living in Eretz Yisroel, where the weather usually allows us to fulfill this mitzvah, we should feel privileged to perform it. Chazal emphasize that Sukkah is one of the few mitzvos fulfilled with our entire body.
May we merit always to be surrounded by mitzvos, and to perform them with joy.
Leave A Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.