“…Like Nimrod the mighty hunter before the Lord.” (Bereishis 10:9)

Rashi: He ensnared the minds of people by his words, misleading them to rebel against the Omnipresent (Genesis Rabbah 37:2).

Ibn Ezra: The meaning of before the Lord is that Nimrod built altars and offered the animals he hunted as whole offerings to God.

The Ramban (Nachmanides 1194–1270) raises a question on the Ibn Ezra (Abraham ben Meir Ibn Ezra 1089-1164), “How can Chazal describe Nimrod as a wicked man, and yet the Ibn Ezra tells us that he brought offerings to Hashem? How can both be true?”

The Beis Yisrael of Ger (Rabbi Yisrael Alter 1895–1977) explains that when a rasha brings a korbon, the korbon is despised by Hashem. Instead of becoming a merit, this act becomes a deficit!

The Satmar Rebbe (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum 1887–1979) offers a different approach. He says that wicked people who want to capture the souls of the innocent often begin by doing good things, presenting themselves as righteous, in order to draw good people towards them, only later leading them to sin. Nimrod’s sacrifices were part of his master plan to corrupt others.

I once heard another explanation, which I would like to share. We tend to assume that when a rasha brings an offering, he does so with the same intent that we have. But the Ramban in Vayikra explains that a person must see himself as represented by the korbon he brings to Hashem. The offering is meant to express a total consecration of oneself to the service of Hashem. This was not Nimrod’s intention. Although it appeared as if he was offering sacrifices to Hashem, in fact he considered himself a deity, and these offerings were acts of self-honor and glorification!

Whatever the meaning of this difficult Ibn Ezra may be, it is clear that two people can perform the exact same action, yet the implications can be entirely opposite. I often illustrate this with the following example: a parent tells a teenager, “I am sure you want to clean up your room.” The teenager answers, “Yeah, sure!” This phrase can be understood as either a definite no or a definite yes. Though the two interpretations contradict each other, both are entirely possible. When I was growing up in America, one of the ways to say something was really good was to say that it was “really bad”.

So too, we must understand that sometimes Chazal offers different explanations that seem to totally contradict each other. Both can be true, just not necessarily at the same time or in the same situation.

Let us take a lesson from Nimrod and ensure that our actions reflect the goodness of our hearts, by doing things with positive intentions, elevating our service of Hashem.